Beyond Extrinsic Reward and Adult Surveillance

This post is just as a bridge to consider how extrinsic reward (that people usually consider good for motivating children) would be harmful for their intrinsic motivation. Furthermore, according to Self-Determination-Theory, it would just be able to move left-side rather than to the right-side.

To gain further information, I highly recommend the readers to read the original complete article or to find more about self determination theory.

How a problem get students engaged

The following video shows how a group of fifth graders work on a realistic problem related to time differences. The problem is adopted from PISA 2006 questions.

What is interesting?
If you listen critically to the conversations, you will find how this problem could engage students in thinking. Solving this problem, the students seems to first imagine themselves involved in the problem. They unintentionally positioned themselves to think of consequences, related to the situation, given in the problem.

Continue reading

Start from “Common Sense”, End with “Understanding”

Summary of the article:
Gravemeijer, K. (2011). How concrete is concrete. Indonesian Mathematics Society Journal on Mathematics Education, 2(1), 1-8.

This might be the answer of the previous problem given in “When nine doughnuts price as much as the other ten”. The real problem is that students sometimes think that mathematics that they learn in school has no relation with what they see in everyday life.

concrete

Dealing with this problem, teachers try to provide students with manipulative which perhaps help them connect the math to the real-world context. Occasionally, those manipulative seemed very realistic for teachers, unfortunately not for students. Teachers are usually trapped with their own thinking and forget that their students are in not in their level.

Continue reading

Understanding Percent using the Percentage Bar

Summary of the article:
Van Galen, F. & D. v. Eerde. (2013). Solving Problems with the Percentage Bar. IndoMS. J.M.E, 4(1), 1-8.

In an observation toward 14 Grade VII students of a achool in the Netherlands, surprising result (only 4 students could solve the problem correctly) was performed by the students when dealing with the following problem:

Soal persen

Trying to solve the problem, the students directly did calculations. None of them tried to make visual representation to see the relations between the given numbers. As the consequence, they often went wrong.

Actually, the students have tried several ways to find the answer like working with equal proportion or playing with the numbers in the question.

The former one was supposed to bring them to the expected result. However, they were stuck since they have to work with unfriendly proportion (15 out of 100) which led them to confused. While the latter one was really out of concept. The students might think that the problem must involve simpler calculation. So, they just tried to divide 600 over 15 and conclude that the answer should be 40.

Continue reading

Rancangan Permasalahan Matematika Berbasis PMRI (Versi Indonesia)

Bilangan (SAUS ES PISANG IJO)
Untuk membuat 6 porsi ‘saus es pisang ijo’, dibutuhkan bahan-bahan sebagai berikut:esp

– 1 liter santan
– 60 gram tepung beras
– 100 gram gula pasir
– 1/2 sdt garam
– 1 lembar daun pandan

Andi ingin membuat ‘saus es pisang ijo’. Ia mempunyai 10 liter santan, 100 gram tepung beras, 1 kg gula, banyak garam, dan 10 lembar daun pandan. Berapa banyak ‘saus es pisang ijo’ kah yang dapat ia buat?

Continue reading

Design of PMRI-based Mathematical Problems (English Version)

Number (ES PISANG IJO SAUCE)

esp

In order to make 6 portions of ‘es pisang ijo sauce’, the following ingredients are required:
– 1 litre of coconut milk
– 60 gram of tepung beras
– 100 gram of sugar
– 1/2 tea spoon of salt
– 1 piece of palm leave

Andi wants to make the sauce, and he has 10 litre of coconut milk, 100 gram of tepung beras, 1 kg of sugar, a lot of salt, 10 pieces of palm leave. How many portion of ‘es pisang ijo sauce’ he could make?

Continue reading